When it comes to 90s sitcoms, two shows stand out for their portrayal of family life and hilarious moments: Family Matters and Step by Step. Both were iconic in their own right, offering us memorable characters, laugh-out-loud moments, and lessons about family dynamics. But when pitted against each other, which sitcom takes the comedic crown? Let’s dive into a head-to-head comparison of Family Matters and Step by Step, analyzing their characters, themes, humor, and overall cultural impact.
A Look Back at Family Matters and Step by Step
Before we compare these two sitcoms, it’s essential to understand the context and premise of each show. Family Matters debuted in 1989, focusing on the Winslow family, a middle-class African American family living in Chicago. The show revolved around Carl Winslow, a no-nonsense cop, his loving wife Harriette, and their kids, with the hilarious nerd Steve Urkel becoming the breakout character. Over time, Family Matters became known for blending slapstick comedy with heartfelt moments.
On the other hand, Step by Step premiered in 1991 as a family-oriented sitcom. The show centered on the blended Foster family, where Frank Lambert, a widower with three children, marries Carol Foster, a divorced mother of three. The comedy emerged from the challenges of blending families, and the show was known for its more traditional sitcom formula, complete with physical comedy and misunderstandings.
Now that we have the basics, let’s break down which show was the better comedy.
Iconic Characters: Family Matters vs. Step by Step
The Winslows: Family Values and Quirky Humor
Family Matters is arguably defined by its unforgettable characters. Carl Winslow, played by Reginald VelJohnson, was the moral backbone of the show. His straight-laced, no-nonsense approach to fatherhood and his growing bond with Steve Urkel, played by Jaleel White, provided plenty of comedy. But it wasn’t just Carl who shone. The Winslow family dynamic, especially Carl’s relationship with his wife Harriette (Jo Marie Payton) and their children Eddie, Laura, and Judy, gave the show its relatable, wholesome charm.
And of course, we can’t forget Steve Urkel, who became the ultimate comic foil. His nerdy antics, love for Laura, and constant catchphrase “Did I do that?” made him the heart and soul of the show. Over time, his character became a central figure, with his presence turning the show into a comedy juggernaut.
The Lamberts and Fosters: The Blended Family Comedy
Step by Step brought a different type of humor with its ensemble cast. Frank Lambert (Patrick Duffy), the widower, and Carol Foster (Suzanne Somers), the divorced mother, formed a classic comedic duo. Their kids, played by a mix of known and lesser-known actors, each had their quirks, making for a dynamic and often chaotic household.
The character of Cody Lambert, played by Sasha Mitchell, was undoubtedly the standout. As the carefree, wild bachelor-turned-brother, Cody’s slapstick humor and eccentricities brought a fresh layer to the sitcom. Much like Steve Urkel, Cody served as the humorous contrast to the more responsible characters.
Humor Style: Family Matters vs. Step by Step
Slapstick vs. Situation Comedy
Both shows excelled in their comedic approach, but their humor styles were quite different. Family Matters often leaned on slapstick comedy, especially with Steve Urkel. His outrageous inventions, clumsy antics, and exaggerated physical humor provided ample laughs. However, Family Matters wasn’t just about physical comedy—it also explored deeper emotional moments, such as family challenges and the importance of community. These moments of heartfelt drama balanced out the humor, giving it a wholesome feel that connected with viewers on multiple levels.
On the other hand, Step by Step embraced more traditional situation comedy. The humor was often derived from misunderstandings, awkward situations, and the challenges of blending two families. The quirky personalities of the characters, such as the absent-minded Frank and the neurotic Carol, created endless opportunities for comedic chaos. While it didn’t dive as deeply into emotional moments as Family Matters, it created a steady rhythm of comedic situations that kept viewers laughing.
The Role of Physical Comedy
Physical comedy was a significant component of both shows. Steve Urkel’s outrageous clumsiness led to some of the most memorable comedic moments in television history, from his accidents in the Winslow household to his wild antics in school. His constant attempts to impress Laura, mixed with his hilarious failures, were a constant source of humor.
In Step by Step, Cody Lambert was the physical comedy king. His quirky movements, oversized personality, and unorthodox way of handling family situations led to countless laugh-out-loud moments. Cody’s clumsy antics were perfect for Step by Step, where physical humor was often combined with classic sitcom misunderstandings.
Themes and Storylines: Family Matters vs. Step by Step
The Heart of Family Matters’ Storytelling
While both shows were family-centric, Family Matters often used humor to explore deeper themes, such as family loyalty, friendship, and social issues. The interactions between Carl and Steve Urkel evolved from comedic annoyance to a genuine father-son relationship, making for a heartwarming dynamic. The show occasionally touched on important life lessons, from overcoming adversity to learning how to deal with bullying or difficult situations at school.
Notable Episodes: The Christmas specials, Carl’s relationship with his kids, and Steve’s attempts at self-improvement are prime examples of how Family Matters blended heartfelt lessons with humor.
Blended Families in Step by Step
Step by Step tackled the complexity of blended families, often presenting comedic scenarios where two very different families tried to live under one roof. The dynamic between Frank and Carol, as well as their children, was fertile ground for funny situations. Step by Step also had a lighter touch when dealing with family issues, focusing on the trials of step-sibling relationships, parental rules, and growing up in a non-traditional household.
Notable Episodes: The holidays, vacations, and major family milestones (like weddings or school dances) were frequently explored in humorous ways, showing how these two sets of kids tried to form their bond despite their differences.
Cultural Impact: Family Matters vs. Step by Step
Family Matters’ Lasting Legacy
Family Matters left an indelible mark on pop culture, especially thanks to Steve Urkel. His catchphrases, his love for Laura, and his nerdy charm have made him a cultural icon. The show also broke ground by being one of the most successful African American-led sitcoms of its time, offering viewers a positive depiction of an African American family.
Step by Step’s Place in 90s TV
While Step by Step may not have had the cultural weight of Family Matters, it certainly found its place in the hearts of fans who tuned in for the escapist comedy and family chaos. As part of the TGIF lineup, it gained a loyal following, and its mix of traditional sitcom humor and family dynamics made it a beloved show for many.
Which Sitcom Wins the Battle?
So, which sitcom reigns supreme in the battle of Family Matters vs. Step by Step? Ultimately, it depends on what you’re looking for in a comedy.
If you prefer a show that mixes humor with heart and delivers emotional moments along with laughs, Family Matters is the clear winner. The strong family values, along with the unforgettable Steve Urkel, make it a timeless classic.
On the other hand, if you’re drawn to lighthearted, situational comedy and enjoy the dynamic of a blended family full of quirky characters, then Step by Step has its charm. It’s an easygoing show that provides consistent laughs without diving too deep into serious issues.
Conclusion
Both Family Matters and Step by Step played vital roles in shaping 90s sitcom culture, but they did so in different ways. Family Matters blended comedy with life lessons and heartfelt moments, while Step by Step leaned into family chaos and physical comedy for laughs. Each show brought something unique to the table, and the debate over which one is better is likely to continue for years to come.
Whether you favor the Winslows or the Lamberts, there’s no denying that these two sitcoms are a significant part of 90s TV history.
FAQs
1. Was Family Matters a more emotional show than Step by Step?
Yes, Family Matters often included emotional moments that dealt with real-life family issues, making it more heartfelt compared to the lighthearted nature of Step by Step.
2. Who was the breakout star of Family Matters?
Steve Urkel, played by Jaleel White, became the breakout star of Family Matters, with his nerdy antics and catchphrases becoming iconic.
3. How did Step by Step approach the concept of blended families?
Step by Step explored the comedic challenges of blending two families, focusing on the humorous aspects of step-sibling relationships and parental rules.
4. Which show had a bigger impact on pop culture?
Family Matters had a larger cultural impact, particularly due to Steve Urkel’s popularity and its representation of an African American family.
5. Did both shows appeal to the same audience?
Both shows were part of the TGIF lineup and attracted similar audiences, but Family Matters had a broader appeal due to its emotional depth and iconic characters.
