Jennifer Lawrence and Brie Larson both vied to play Twilight’s Bella Swan, but director Catherine Hardwicke does not even remember their auditions.
Twilight director Catherine Hardwicke discloses her reaction to two major actresses’ auditions for Bella. Hardwicke directed the first Twilight film, which was released in 2008. The film starred an up-and-coming Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan opposite Robert Pattinson’s Edward Cullen.
Hardwicke reveals that both Jennifer Lawrence and Brie Larson auditioned for the role of Bella, though the director barely remembers their auditions. Speaking with Josh Horowitz, Hardwicke revealed that she had her “eyes set on” Stewart “very early on” in the process.
Because of this, she cannot even remember if Larson or Lawrence “actually came in to see [her],” as she was so distracted by her desire for Stewart to play the role
Why Kristen Stewart Was The Better Choice For Bella Swan
While they have since risen to mainstream prominence, all three actresses would have been in the early stages of their careers at the time. In 2008, Lawrence was only 18 years old, not yet having acted in her breakout roles in Winter’s Bone and X-Men: First Class. Larson would have been 19 at the time, but she was similarly unknown at the time of Twilight’s casting.
As showcased by their later roles in films like Room and Winter’s Bone, respectively, both Larson and Lawrence would have brought an intense teenage angst that is far different from that of Stewart. Both actresses have a propensity for the highly dramatic, something that Lawrence used to her advantage a few years after Twilight when she took on the leading role of Katniss Everdeen in The Hunger Games. If cast as Bella Swan, either Larson or Lawrence might have given Twilight a more serious dramatic angle than the Stewart version did.
That said, it is fascinating to hear Hardwicke’s take on Stewart’s ability to play Bella. While some may have accused Stewart of being too wooden in the role, Hardwick is right that “she’s never going to overact” on screen. As Stewart has proven time and time again throughout her post-Twilight career, her composure can lend itself to unique character rhythms. Stewart expertly contributed this understated style to Twilight, making Bella Swan into the alluring character she is known as today.
